The Postman Always Rings Twice


This page is obsolete. See the newer version.






abstract | news | pictures | content repository | donations | papers | seminar | talks | people


Why does the postman ring twice? Answer: once for traditional paper (analog) content and twice for digital data.

The Digital StudyHall is an educational project that seeks to help the poor children in slum and rural schools in India. In a nutshell, think of the project as the educational equivalent of Netflix combined with YouTube. We digitally record live classes by the best teachers in good schools in cities, and distribute them on DVDs to poor rural and slum schools. Among other things, the content is used to train village teachers and allow poor kids to teach themselves. The project is a collaboration between computer scientists and education experts.



Abstract:

Good primary education is one of the most crucial factors in combating extreme poverty. In this project, computer scientists and education experts collaborate to build a distance learning system that seeks to offer resource-starved schools in villages and urban slums of India human and content resources comparable to that received by middle-class students in cities. To avoid retracing the missteps of earlier "wire-the-schools" projects, we follow two important principles: (1) cost realism, essential if we are to scale the system up to a significant number of schools and students; and (2) building systems that solve end-to-end education problems, beyond just providing connectivity, so the twin pillars of technology and pedagogy must develop side by side.

Our Digital StudyHall system is based on a unique approach leveraging the postal system, DVDs, robotically operated DVD publishers, long-distance ham radio transceivers, and short-range TV transmitters with radio controllers. We combine these components into a general-purpose and transparent communication system, providing pervasive, high-bandwidth, and low-cost connectivity. On top of this, we layer a web repository, called the "learning eBay" to enable a wide variety of digital education "workflows," such as lecture capture and replay, remote monitoring, student project collection and feedback, connecting learners and teaching staff across time and space, including volunteers from overseas. The system consists of a network of hubs and spokes, where the "hubs" are typically distributed in urban centers of excellence, which "radiate" contextually meaningful and coherent content and methodology into village and slum schools in their vicinity, which form the "spokes." An important goal of the system is to enable customized any-to-any communication and effective group learning, which may provide an ultimate solution to the scalability problem of the education system.

The pedagogy practiced in the system is based on the theory of "Tutored Video Instruction," where remote expertise is projected into a classroom, mediated by a local less well trained teacher. This approach goes way beyond passive TV watching; it requires the local teachers to perform a variety of activities to proactively engage their students while alternately playing and pausing the pre-recorded videos. In a sense, the video and the local teacher form a "team:" the video provides a framework, an agenda, and a content and methodology model; while the local teacher supplies the crucial interactive components. In addition to helping the students, the process provides excellent training to the less skilled local teachers. Unlike conventional training workshops that last only for a short period of time and can be too abstract, the kind of training a local teacher receives from the supplied videos is ongoing, continuous, and highly specific.

A live deployment of the DSH prototype has been in use by students and teachers in and around the Lucknow hub starting in July of 2005. Starting in the summer of 2006, we have launched two more hubs in Bangalore and in Pune. In the space of one and a half years, we have accumulated about 400 high-quality MPEG4 recordings of lessons staged by the best teachers at the hubs. The remaining 150 objects include science courseware, digital stories, and recordings of drama performances, all of which are produced by students and staff at the Lucknow hub school. The languages used in the content include Hindi, Kannada, Tamil, Marathi, and English. As the high-quality content is quickly and cheaply generated, it is being continuously pushed out to a variety of rural and urban slum pilot schools around the hubs. Preliminary results appear promising, and the system seems to be playing an effective but subtle role of blurring class differences in a highly stratified society. We hope to eventually scale up the system to cover a far greater number of villages and children, contributing toward the Millennium Development Goal of universal primary education.

Please read on for more details.





News:

Pictures

Mailing lists:


A Mirror of the Lucknow Content Repository:

The Seattle mirror of Lucknow



Donations:

Please consider making a donation to the project. The Digital StudyHall is an official 501c3 non-profit organization. Donations to the project are fully tax-deductable. All funds will go to funding local "foot soldiers" or equipment purchase. Thank you!



Papers:

The DSH Team. The Digital StudyHall. (For the Mona Foundation,) January 2007. (pdf or html)

Randolph Wang, Urvashi Sahni, Nitin Garg, Anindita Dasgupta, Sumeet Sobti, Tanuja Setia, and Thomas Anderson. Digital Networking Going Postal and a Tale of Three Schools. (For the India-based Small Change magazine,) January 2006. (pdf or html)

Randolph Wang, Urvashi Sahni, Sumeet Sobti, Nitin Garg, Jaswinder Pal Singh, Matthew Kam, Arvind Krishnamurthy, and Thomas Anderson. The Digital StudyHall. Technical Report TR-723-05, Computer Science Department, Princeton University. March 2005. (pdf or html)     

Nitin Garg. A Postal System Based Digital Network And A Distance Learning Application. PhD thesis, Computer Science Department, Princeton University. June 2006. (pdf)     

Nitin Garg, Sumeet Sobti, Junwen Lai, Fengzhou Zheng, Kai Li, Arvind Krishnamurthy, and Randolph Wang. Bridging the digital divide: storage media + postal network = generic high-bandwidth communication. ACM Transactions on Storage (TOS), Volume 1, Issue 2. May 2005.

Nitin Garg, Sumeet Sobti, Junwen Lai, Fengzhou Zheng, Kai Li, Arvind Krishnamurthy, and Randolph Wang. Networking Going Postal. Technical Report TR-705-04, Computer Science Department, Princeton University. May 2004.

Randolph Wang, Sumeet Sobti, Nitin Garg, Elisha Ziskind, Junwen Lai, and Arvind Krishnamurthy. Turning the Postal System into a Generic Digital Communication Mechanism. Proc. ACM SIGCOMM 2004. August 2004.

Junwen Lai, Elisha Ziskind, Fengzhou Zheng, Yilei Shao, Chi Zhang, Ming Zhang, Nitin Garg, Sumeet Sobti, Randolph Wang, and Arvind Krishnamurthy. Distance Learning Technologies for Basic Education in Disadvantaged Areas. The 8th Global Chinese Conference on Computers in Education. June 2004.

Randolph Wang, Nitin Garg, Sumeet Sobti, Junwen Lai, Elisha Ziskind, Fengzhou Zheng, Akihiro Nakao, and Arvind Krishnamurthy. Postmanet: Turning the Postal System into a Generic Digital Communication Mechanism. Technical Report TR-691-04, Computer Science Department, Princeton University. February 2004. (pdf or html)

Randolph Wang, Kai Li, and Margaret Martonosi. Turning the Postal System into a Generic Digital Communication Mechanism. Technical Report TR-688-04, Computer Science Department, Princeton University. January 2004. (pdf or html)

Randolph Wang, Kai Li, Margaret Martonosi, and Arvind Krishnamurthy. Distance Learning Technologies for Basic Education in Disadvantaged Areas. Technical Report TR-685-03, Computer Science Department, Princeton University. November 2003. (pdf or html)      (or its Chinese translation: pdf or html)



Talks:

To view the MPEG4 .avi movies of the recorded talks listed below, you need to install an XviD codec. (futher trouble-shooting tips.)

The Digital StudyHall: Improving Education in Rural India. "TechFest 2007." Microsoft Research. Redmond, Washington. March 8, 2007. slides (.ppt, 60MB), voice (.mp3, including questions, 46min, 8.3MB), slides movie (.avi, 35min, 56MB), talking head movie (.asf, 46min, 100MB).

The Digital StudyHall: Improving Education in Rural India. Harvey Mudd College. Ontario, California. March 7, 2007. slides (.ppt, 59MB), voice (.mp3, including questions, 91min, 17MB), movie (.avi, 56min, 72MB).

Paul Javid. Experience with setting up Digital StudyHall in Bangalore. Microsoft Research India. Bangalore, India. December 15, 2006. slides (.ppt, 27MB), movie (.avi, 43MB).

Paul Javid. The Digital StudyHall. Microsoft Research India. Bangalore, India. October 9, 2006. slides (.ppt, 9.6MB), movie (.avi, 41MB).

The Digital StudyHall. Synopsys India. Bangalore, India. September 14, 2006. slides (.pdf, 55MB), slides (.jpg), voice (.mp3, including questions, 100min, 18MB), movie (.avi, 42min, 41MB).

The Digital StudyHall. Microsoft Research India. Bangalore, India. September 14, 2006. slides (.pdf, 55MB), slides (.jpg), voice (.mp3, 41min, 7.5MB), movie (.avi, 41min, 41MB).

The Digital StudyHall. Microsoft Research India. Bangalore, India. July 5, 2006. slides (.pdf, 84MB), voice (.mp3, 130min, 24MB), movie (.avi, 130min, 129MB).

The Digital StudyHall: An E-Learning System for Improving Basic Education in Third World Countries. NJIT. Newark, New Jersey. April 27, 2006. slides (.pdf, 84MB), voice (.mp3, 80min, 14MB), movie (.avi, 80min, 80MB).

The Digital StudyHall: An E-Learning System for Improving Basic Education in Third World Countries. Princeton University. Princeton, New Jersey. April 25, 2006. slides (.pdf, 84MB), voice (.mp3, 65min, 12MB), movie (.avi, 65min, 66MB).

The Digital StudyHall: e-learning in rural India. IBM Watson Research Center. Hawthorne, New York. November 9, 2005. slides (.pdf, 49MB), voice (.mp3, 69min, 8.2MB).

The Digital StudyHall: e-learning in rural India. ICTD 2006 Workshop. Berkeley, CA. October 28, 2005. slides (.pdf, 46MB), voice (.mp3, 44min, 7.9MB).

The Digital StudyHall: e-learning in rural India. Colloquium (recorded by UW staff). University of Washington. Seattle, Washington. October 20, 2005. slides (.pdf, 50MB), voice (.mp3, 86min, 21MB), movie (download) (.wmv, 320x240, 86min, 182MB), movie (download) (.wmv, 640x480, 86min, MB), movie (streamed) (.wmv, 640x480, 86min), movie (streamed) (.wmv, 320x240, 86min).

The Digital StudyHall: e-learning in rural India. Colloquium (recorded from the laptop). University of Washington. Seattle, Washington. October 20, 2005. slides (.pdf, 50MB), voice (.mp3, 66min, 12MB), voice (questions) (.mp3, 16min, 2.9MB), movie (.avi, 68min, 218MB).

The Digital StudyHall: e-learning in rural India. Microsoft Research Asia. Beijing, China. August 22, 2005. slides (.pdf, 46MB), voice (.mp3, 73min, 13MB), movie (.avi, 73min, 238MB).

The Digital StudyHall: e-learning in rural India. Google. Mountain View, California. May 25, 2005. slides (.pdf, 20MB), voice (.mp3, 72min, 13MB), movie (.avi, 60min, 48MB).

The Digital StudyHall: e-learning in rural India. Industrial Affiliates Meeting. Princeton University. Princeton, New Jersey. May 4, 2005. slides (.pdf, 17MB), voice (.mp3, 32min, 7.7MB), movie (.avi, 32min, 32MB).

Postmanet. University of Washington. Seattle, Washington. October 27, 2004. slides (.ppt, 9.6MB), voice (.mp3, 76min, 9.2MB), movie (.avi, 76min, 72.2MB).

Postmanet. Bell Labs. Murray Hill, New Jersey. September 10, 2004. slides (.ppt, 9.1MB), voice (.mp3, 59min, 7.0MB), movie (.avi, 59min, 46.4MB).

Postmanet. ACM SIGCOMM 2004. Portland, Oregon. September 1, 2004. slides (.ppt, 9.1MB), voice (.mp3, 38min, 4.6MB), movie (.avi, 38min, 30.3MB).

Postmanet. AT&T Labs. Florham Park, New Jersey. August 5, 2004. slides (.ppt, 8.4MB), voice (.mp3, 51min, 6.2MB), movie (.avi, 51min, 41.9MB).

e-Learning for disadvantaged areas. The 8th Global Chinese Conference on Computers in Education. Hong Kong. June 2, 2004. slides (.ppt, 5.2MB), voice (.mp3, 22min, 2.7MB).



People:

Randy Wang, Urvashi Sahni, Nitin Garg, Sumeet Sobti, Tanuja Setia, Anindita Dasgupta, Tom Anderson, Colin Dixon, Freeman Murray, Paul Javid, Richard Anderson, Bhagya Rangachar, Sandhya Gatti, Channa Raju, Suman Kaverappa, Madhavi Kapur, Zareer Aga, Rajesh Veeraraghavan, Rikin Gandhi, Kentaro Toyama, and others... Digital StudyHall is partially supported by Microsoft Research India.



Seminar:

Technologies for the developing world (spring, 2005)



Key words: DSH, the Digital StudyHall, Study Hall, e-learning, distance learning, primary education, pedagogy, rural, urban slums, India, Postmanet, postman, postal system, network, networking, EdTV, learning eBay, technology, DVD robots, short-range TV transmitters, hubs and spokes, Tutored Video Instruction, TVI, teacher training, scalable, scalability, low cost, cost realism, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, Hindi, digital stories, drama, courseware, recordings, Madantoosi, Kannar, SEWA, BETI, Pune, Bangalore, Sulagiri, Shoolagiri,


© 2005-2007    The Digital StudyHall